Something is wrong on our side. See status.
Skip to content

Methodology

This page explains how a MootDocket case gets made, how it presents its legal elements, how your score works, and what its limits are.

How a case is made

Every case starts with a fictional fact pattern written to test a specific set of Pennsylvania criminal charges. The writer builds the testimony, exhibits, and objections around that pattern, then drafts an answer key that marks each element proven, not proven, or unclear from the record alone.

Statute text on the Penal Code tab is copied verbatim from the official Pennsylvania legislature website, with a source link and a retrieval date. No statute text is ever paraphrased or generated from memory.

How elements are presented

Each charge is broken into its plain statutory elements, listed with the charge's name and nothing specific to the case attached to the element text itself. You mark every element proven, not proven, or unsure based only on what the testimony and exhibits actually show.

The correct verdict for a count is guilty only if every one of its elements is proven. Any other combination points to not guilty, and there is no majority rule across elements.

How the score works

Your score has two parts. Seventy percent compares your element findings against the answer key, and thirty percent checks whether your written verdict for each count actually follows from your own findings on that count's elements.

The score is not a prediction of what a real jury would decide, and it is not a grade on your writing. It only measures how closely your findings and verdicts track the record you were given.

What "compare with the record" means

After you submit your verdict, MootDocket shows you the answer key's own finding for each element and, if you choose to read it, the true story behind the case. Comparing with the record means seeing where your reading of the testimony matched the answer key and where it did not.

It does not mean a real jury reached that outcome, because no real jury exists for a fictional case. It means the case's own written record supports that reading of each element.

Limitations

A real trial takes days and follows procedure that would not fit a short case, so MootDocket simplifies it on purpose. You get the full record at once instead of requesting it piece by piece, and you deliberate alone rather than as part of a twelve-person jury.

Every case is set in Pennsylvania, so the elements and procedure reflect Pennsylvania law specifically, not every state's law. The full list of simplifications is on the About page.

Review policy

A case is reviewed by a legal professional before it is published. The reviewer checks the statute text, the elements, the answer key, and the case's internal consistency against the record it presents.

A case's changelog and review status track whether that review has happened, and an unreviewed case is never published. If you find an error in a published case, use the Contact page or the Report link inside the case itself.